Planning Appeals Register

RECORD OF APPEALS AGAINST THE COUNCIL LODGED WITH THE WELSH ASSEMBLY GOVERNMENT'S PLANNING INSPECTORATE (INCLUDING ENFORCEMENT) (2005)

List last updated:- 02nd March 2007

* No information available

Appeal No. Appellant Site Address Development Planning Application No. Appeal Start Date Decision & Date

App/U6925/A/04/1138779 Mr Tahir Karim
Dan-y-Garreg, Upper High Street, Cefn Coed
Unauthorised Taxi Business Enforcement 22/01/04
Notice upheld as varied 07/06/04

App/U6925/A/04/1143060 Mr & Mrs Saunders
52 Anthony Grove, Abercanaid
First Floor Extension P/03/0505 27/02/04
Dismissed

08/06/04

App/U6925/A/04/1142596 Mr K L Thomas 71 Mardy Street, Mountain Hare Pigeon Loft (retention) Enforcement 27/02/04 Dismissed 26 May 2004

App/U6925/A/04/1138369 Mr R Andrews 3 Millfield, Quakers Yard Erection of Conservatory P/03/0434 19/01/04 Allowed 30/04/04

App/U6925/A/04/1139071 Mr & Mrs Smith 18 Taff Vale Estate, Edwardsville Erection of rear dormer window and front balcony P/03/0513 26/01/04 Dismissed 24/05/04

App/U6925/A/04/1140273 Mrs P E Thomas 6 Poplar Place Retention of Porch P/03/0492 05/02/04 Dismissed 24/05/04

App/U6925/A/03/1132793 Mrs K Blackwell 68 Westview Crescent Side Extension P/03/0428 02/03/04 Allowed 02/03/04

App/U6925/A/04/1140581 Mr J Howfield 39 High Street Roller Shutter Doors P/03/0568 06/02/04 Dismissed 13/05/04

App/U6925/A/04/1158496 Mr R Burnell 22 James Street, Twynyrodyn Extension P/04/0178 26/08/04 Allowed 01/12/04

App/U6925/A/04/1150396 Mr I Kepil 39 Fox Street, Treharris Change of use to cafe/takeaway (Class A3 use)[Col 4 Row 11] P/03/0573 14/05/04
Allowed 02/09/04

App/U6925/A/04/1148787 Quantum Enterprises (Aberdare) Ltd Land adjacent to Brondeg, Heolgerrig Residential Development (16 plots) P/04/0018 16/01/04
Dismissed

10/09/04

App/U6925/A/04/1151306 Mr C W Baynton 67 The Oaks, Ty Llwyd Park, Quakers Yard Erection of First Floor Extension over the existing garage P/04/0076 25/05/04 Dismissed 20/09/04

App/U6925/A/04/1147709 Mr K Jones Ann's Close (previous playground) 2 New Private Dwellings P/04/0014 15/04/04 Allowed 26/07/04

App/U6925/A/04/1164800 Morlais Castle Golf Club Morlais Castle Golf Course Reprofiling to form two new Greens P/03/0421 28/10/04 Withdrawn 01/02/05

App/U6925/A/04/1162138 Mr A James & Mrs James "Bailey Glas", Heolgerrig Residential Development (one house) P/04/0187 29/11/04
Dismissed 22/02/05

App/U6925/A/04/1162241 Mr & Mrs A D Cole Coedmeyrick Close, Swansea Road Garage to front garden P/04/0166 19/10/04 Allowed 07/02/05

App/U6925/C/04/1152548 Mr N Jones Old Bakery Site, Troedyrhiw Unauthorised Siting of 1 No. Storage Container P/03/0412 08/06/04 Dismissed 05/10/04

App/U6925/A/04/1169049 Mr D L & Mrs L J Humphreys 48 Galon Uchaf Road Two storey side extension P/04/0501 13/12/04 Allowed 22/03/05

App/U6925/A/04/1162235 Ms D Powell Goede'r Coed, Cefn Coed 2 No. Homes P/04/0131 21/12/04 Allowed 12/01/05

App/U6925/A/04/1169791 Mr & Mrs Thomas Erection of Dwelling 1 Fothergill Street, Penyard P/04/0389 13/12/04 Dismissed 22/03/05

App/U6925/A/04/1171462 Mrs P & Mr G Thomas 23 Chepstow Close, Castle Park, CF48 1JG Retention of Conservatory P/04/0220 30/12/04 Allowed 06/04/05

App/U6925/A/04/1168166 Francesca Bosley & Darren Lewis 13 Azalea Park, Old Forge Park Two storey side and rear extension P/04/0226 23/12/04 Dismissed 30/03/05

App/U6925/A/04/1169017 Mr G A Tuck Land adjacent to 'Y Goedwig', Cardiff Road, Edwardsville Residential Development (Outline) P/03/0476 02/12/04 Allowed 18/03/05

App/U6925/A/05/1175532 Andrew J Evans 5 Courtland Terrace Provision of car parking bays (2 no.) P/04/0311 07/03/05
Dismissed 01/06/05

App/U6925/A/05/1177584 Reginald Moore Ltd Land at the Hollies, Ty Llwyd Parc, Quakers Yard Construction of 7 dwellings P/04/0063 07/04/05
Dismissed 05/07/05

App/U6925/A/05/1178288 Ms C Williams 37 Gethin Street, Abercanaid Private Garage P/05/0018 05/05/05
Allowed 09/08/05

App/U6925/A/05/1178710 K Lang 15 Chepstow Close, Castle Park Erection of two storey side extension and garage P/04/0542 18/05/05
Dismissed 16/08/05

App/U6925/A/05/1181591 Mr M Sunny Land adjacent to Thorn Hill, Pantanas, Treharris Residential Development comprising 2 No. houses with detached garages and associated road. P/04/0294 13/06/05
Allowed 28/09/05

App/U6925/A/05/1182930 Mr N Smith Land fronting 23 Winchfawr, Heolgerrig, Merthyr Tydfil, CF48 1TL Four bedroom detached house with integral garage P/04/0582 20/06/05
Dismissed 07/09/05

App/U6925/A/05/1181076 Mr & Mrs Baker 14 Monmouth Drive, Castle Park Retention of Conservatory P/05/0104 16/06/05 Dismissed 23/09/05

App/U6925/A/05/1176993 Mr J Peacock 38 Fox Street, Treharris Conversion of shop/residential unit to 2 flats P/05/0005 12/04/05
Allowed 13/07/05

APP/U6925/A/05/1176457 Mr J D Evans 98 Cilhaul, Treharris Retention of Porch P/04/0476 08/04/2005 Allowed 05/08/05

APP/U6925/A/05/1186117 Mr A Mahoney Land adjoining 14 Salisbury Close, Heolgerrig Change of use of land to form part of curtilage serving 14 Salisbury Close and erection of 1.8m high boundary enclosures P/05/0141 08/08/05
Allowed 09/11/05

APP/U6925/A/05/1180353 S & J Edwards 89 Cilhaul, Treharris Retention of porch P/05/0034 20/05/05
Allowed 06/09/05

APP/U6925/A/05/1192018 S Flaherty 3 Alma Terrace, Dowlais Change of use to childminders P/05/0236 03/11/05
Dismissed

20/02/06

APP/U6925/A/05/1190203 Mr C Humphreys 17 Urban Street, Penydarren New detached garage P/05/0347 04/10/2005 Dismissed 11/01/06

App/U6925/A/05/1195991
Ms C Goddard
Hawthorns, The Villas, Edwardsville, Treharris, CF46 5NH
Partial removal of front boundary wall to allow creation of front driveway and creation of vehicular crossover P/05/0387 10/07/2005
Dismissed

16/08/2005

App/U6925/A/05/1196030 Mr M Lynn 3 Newfoundland Terrace, Abermorlais, Merthyr Tydfil, CF47 8LA Dormer window P/05/0294 26/05/2005
Dismissed

15/03/2006

App/U6925/A/05/1196051 Mr A J Lewis Land adjacent to Dalry, Upper High Street, Cefn Coed, Merthyr Tydfil Erection of one detached dwelling P/05/0542 29/12/2005
Allowed

11/04/2006

App/U6925/A/06/1197368 Mr W T Evans Windy View Bungalow, Mountain Hare, Merthyr Tydfil Erection of conservatory conversion of garage to bedroom and other internal alterations P/05/0511 18/01/2006
Allowed

25/04/2006

App/U6925/A/06/1198125 Mr A McDonnell 24 Mitchell Crescent, Penydarren, Merthyr Tydfil Refurbishment of front, side and rear elevation of building, new roof and erection of 2 storey and single storey side extension (incorporating) integral garage P/06/0002 13/03/2006
Allowed

25/05/2006

App/U6925/A/06/1198586 Mr I Llewellyn 15 Pembroke Close, Castle Park, Merthyr Tydfil Erection of single storey extension P/05/0641 26/04/2006
Allowed

09/08/2006

App/U6920/A/06/1198449 Mr P Kelleher 2 Efail Shingrig, Treharris Residential development (Outline) P/05/0340 04/04/2006
Allowed

18/07/2006

App/U6925/A/06/1198384 Paul Kent & Kate Lloyd Jones
Ty Chwarel, adjacent to 15 The Park, Treharris
Erection of dwellinghouse P/05/0578 28/03/2006 Allowed 29/08/2006

App/U6925/A/06/1199826 Keith Morgan Oxenham 19 Raglan Grove, Castle Park Extension to conservatory P/06/0188 08/09/2006

App/U6925/A/06/1198891 Messrs Treharne and Price Land to the rear of Susannah Place, Prosser Street and Windsor Place, Treharris Residential Development P/05/0408 02/06/2006 Allowed 22/09/06

App/U6925/A/06/1198995 Mr L Williams Unit 13 EFI Industrial Estate, Brecon Road Extension to Existing Industrial Unit P/06/0020 02/06/2006

App/U6925/C/041168237 Michael Barrie Lynn 3 Newfoundlound Terrace, Merthyr Tydfil Dormer window front roof plane No planning application made 09/12/04
Dismissed

05/04/05

App/U6925/C/061200042, 1200043, 1200044, 1200045, 1200646 Mr MS Davies, Mrs BA Davies and Miss FG Davies Ein LLe Hedychlon, Pontycapel Road, Cefn Coed Unauthorised dwelling and stables P/01/0345 27/10/06

App/U6925/A/06/1200210 Miss C Miles 20 The Grove, Aberfan First floor and two storey rear extension P/06/0401

02/11/06

Allowed

17/01/07

App/U6925/A/06/1199826 Mr K Oxenham 19 Raglan Grive, Castle Park, Merthyr Tydfil Extension to a conservatory P/06/0188 08/09/06
Dismissed

12/12/06

App/U6925/A/061200300 Miss N Mullins 1 Bishops Grove Erection of side garage and rear conservatory P/06/0283 09/11/06 Allowed 17/01/07

App/U6925/A/06/1200323 Mr and Mrs P Dacey 6 Chepstow Close, Castle Park, CF48 1JG Front conservatory P/06/0263 10/11/06

Rate this page

How would you rate the quality of this content, 1 being poor and 5 being good?

Comments

RECORD OF APPEALS AGAINST THE COUNCIL LODGED WITH THE WELSH ASSEMBLY GOVERNMENT'S PLANNING INSPECTORATE (INCLUDING ENFORCEMENT) (2005)

Whats New

Appeal No.	Appellant	Site Address	Development	Planning Application No.	Appeal Start Date	Decision & Date
App/U6925/A/04/1138779	Mr Tahir Karim	Dan-y-Garreg, Upper High Street, Cefn Coed	Unauthorised Taxi Business	Enforcement	22/01/04	Notice upheld as varied 07/06/04
App/U6925/A/04/1143060	Mr & Mrs Saunders	52 Anthony Grove, Abercanaid	First Floor Extension	P/03/0505	27/02/04	Dismissed 08/06/04
App/U6925/A/04/1142596	Mr K L Thomas	71 Mardy Street, Mountain Hare	Pigeon Loft (retention)	Enforcement	27/02/04	Dismissed 26 May 2004
App/U6925/A/04/1138369	Mr R Andrews	3 Millfield, Quakers Yard	Erection of Conservatory	P/03/0434	19/01/04	Allowed 30/04/04
App/U6925/A/04/1139071	Mr & Mrs Smith	18 Taff Vale Estate, Edwardsville	Erection of rear dormer window and front balcony	P/03/0513	26/01/04	Dismissed 24/05/04
App/U6925/A/04/1140273	Mrs P E Thomas	6 Poplar Place	Retention of Porch	P/03/0492	05/02/04	Dismissed 24/05/04
App/U6925/A/03/1132793	Mrs K Blackwell	68 Westview Crescent	Side Extension	P/03/0428	02/03/04	Allowed 02/03/04
App/U6925/A/04/1140581	Mr J Howfield	39 High Street	Roller Shutter Doors	P/03/0568	06/02/04	Dismissed 13/05/04
App/U6925/A/04/1158496	Mr R Burnell	22 James Street, Twynyrodyn	Extension	P/04/0178	26/08/04	Allowed 01/12/04
App/U6925/A/04/1150396	Mr I Kepil	39 Fox Street, Treharris	Change of use to cafe/takeaway (Class A3 use)[Col 4 Row 11]	P/03/0573	14/05/04	Allowed 02/09/04
App/U6925/A/04/1148787	Quantum Enterprises (Aberdare) Ltd	Land adjacent to Brondeg, Heolgerrig	Residential Development (16 plots)	P/04/0018	16/01/04	Dismissed 10/09/04
App/U6925/A/04/1151306	Mr C W Baynton	67 The Oaks, Ty Llwyd Park, Quakers Yard	Erection of First Floor Extension over the existing garage	P/04/0076	25/05/04	Dismissed 20/09/04
App/U6925/A/04/1147709	Mr K Jones	Ann's Close (previous playground)	2 New Private Dwellings	P/04/0014	15/04/04	Allowed 26/07/04
App/U6925/A/04/1164800	Morlais Castle Golf Club	Morlais Castle Golf Course	Reprofiling to form two new Greens	P/03/0421	28/10/04	Withdrawn 01/02/05
App/U6925/A/04/1162138	Mr A James & Mrs James	"Bailey Glas", Heolgerrig	Residential Development (one house)	P/04/0187	29/11/04	Dismissed 22/02/05
App/U6925/A/04/1162241	Mr & Mrs A D Cole	Coedmeyrick Close, Swansea Road	Garage to front garden	P/04/0166	19/10/04	Allowed 07/02/05
App/U6925/C/04/1152548	Mr N Jones	Old Bakery Site, Troedyrhiw	Unauthorised Siting of 1 No. Storage Container	P/03/0412	08/06/04	Dismissed 05/10/04
App/U6925/A/04/1169049	Mr D L & Mrs L J Humphreys	48 Galon Uchaf Road	Two storey side extension	P/04/0501	13/12/04	Allowed 22/03/05
App/U6925/A/04/1162235	Ms D Powell	Goede'r Coed, Cefn Coed	2 No. Homes	P/04/0131	21/12/04	Allowed 12/01/05
App/U6925/A/04/1169791	Mr & Mrs Thomas	Erection of Dwelling	1 Fothergill Street, Penyard	P/04/0389	13/12/04	Dismissed 22/03/05
App/U6925/A/04/1171462	Mrs P & Mr G Thomas	23 Chepstow Close, Castle Park, CF48 1JG	Retention of Conservatory	P/04/0220	30/12/04	Allowed 06/04/05
App/U6925/A/04/1168166	Francesca Bosley & Darren Lewis	13 Azalea Park, Old Forge Park	Two storey side and rear extension	P/04/0226	23/12/04	Dismissed 30/03/05
App/U6925/A/04/1169017	Mr G A Tuck	Land adjacent to 'Y Goedwig', Cardiff Road, Edwardsville	Residential Development (Outline)	P/03/0476	02/12/04	Allowed 18/03/05
App/U6925/A/05/1175532	Andrew J Evans	5 Courtland Terrace	Provision of car parking bays (2 no.)	P/04/0311	07/03/05	Dismissed 01/06/05
App/U6925/A/05/1177584	Reginald Moore Ltd	Land at the Hollies, Ty Llwyd Parc, Quakers Yard	Construction of 7 dwellings	P/04/0063	07/04/05	Dismissed 05/07/05
App/U6925/A/05/1178288	Ms C Williams	37 Gethin Street, Abercanaid	Private Garage	P/05/0018	05/05/05	Allowed 09/08/05
App/U6925/A/05/1178710	K Lang	15 Chepstow Close, Castle Park	Erection of two storey side extension and garage	P/04/0542	18/05/05	Dismissed 16/08/05
App/U6925/A/05/1181591	Mr M Sunny	Land adjacent to Thorn Hill, Pantanas, Treharris	Residential Development comprising 2 No. houses with detached garages and associated road.	P/04/0294	13/06/05	Allowed 28/09/05
App/U6925/A/05/1182930	Mr N Smith	Land fronting 23 Winchfawr, Heolgerrig, Merthyr Tydfil, CF48 1TL	Four bedroom detached house with integral garage	P/04/0582	20/06/05	Dismissed 07/09/05
App/U6925/A/05/1181076	Mr & Mrs Baker	14 Monmouth Drive, Castle Park	Retention of Conservatory	P/05/0104	16/06/05	Dismissed 23/09/05
App/U6925/A/05/1176993	Mr J Peacock	38 Fox Street, Treharris	Conversion of shop/residential unit to 2 flats	P/05/0005	12/04/05	Allowed 13/07/05
APP/U6925/A/05/1176457	Mr J D Evans	98 Cilhaul, Treharris	Retention of Porch	P/04/0476	08/04/2005	Allowed 05/08/05
APP/U6925/A/05/1186117	Mr A Mahoney	Land adjoining 14 Salisbury Close, Heolgerrig	Change of use of land to form part of curtilage serving 14 Salisbury Close and erection of 1.8m high boundary enclosures	P/05/0141	08/08/05	Allowed 09/11/05
APP/U6925/A/05/1180353	S & J Edwards	89 Cilhaul, Treharris	Retention of porch	P/05/0034	20/05/05	Allowed 06/09/05
APP/U6925/A/05/1192018	S Flaherty	3 Alma Terrace, Dowlais	Change of use to childminders	P/05/0236	03/11/05	Dismissed 20/02/06
APP/U6925/A/05/1190203	Mr C Humphreys	17 Urban Street, Penydarren	New detached garage	P/05/0347	04/10/2005	Dismissed 11/01/06
App/U6925/A/05/1195991	Ms C Goddard	Hawthorns, The Villas, Edwardsville, Treharris, CF46 5NH	Partial removal of front boundary wall to allow creation of front driveway and creation of vehicular crossover	P/05/0387	10/07/2005	Dismissed 16/08/2005
App/U6925/A/05/1196030	Mr M Lynn	3 Newfoundland Terrace, Abermorlais, Merthyr Tydfil, CF47 8LA	Dormer window	P/05/0294	26/05/2005	Dismissed 15/03/2006
App/U6925/A/05/1196051	Mr A J Lewis	Land adjacent to Dalry, Upper High Street, Cefn Coed, Merthyr Tydfil	Erection of one detached dwelling	P/05/0542	29/12/2005	Allowed 11/04/2006
App/U6925/A/06/1197368	Mr W T Evans	Windy View Bungalow, Mountain Hare, Merthyr Tydfil	Erection of conservatory conversion of garage to bedroom and other internal alterations	P/05/0511	18/01/2006	Allowed 25/04/2006
App/U6925/A/06/1198125	Mr A McDonnell	24 Mitchell Crescent, Penydarren, Merthyr Tydfil	Refurbishment of front, side and rear elevation of building, new roof and erection of 2 storey and single storey side extension (incorporating) integral garage	P/06/0002	13/03/2006	Allowed 25/05/2006
App/U6925/A/06/1198586	Mr I Llewellyn	15 Pembroke Close, Castle Park, Merthyr Tydfil	Erection of single storey extension	P/05/0641	26/04/2006	Allowed 09/08/2006
App/U6920/A/06/1198449	Mr P Kelleher	2 Efail Shingrig, Treharris	Residential development (Outline)	P/05/0340	04/04/2006	Allowed 18/07/2006
App/U6925/A/06/1198384	Paul Kent & Kate Lloyd Jones	Ty Chwarel, adjacent to 15 The Park, Treharris	Erection of dwellinghouse	P/05/0578	28/03/2006	Allowed 29/08/2006
App/U6925/A/06/1199826	Keith Morgan Oxenham	19 Raglan Grove, Castle Park	Extension to conservatory	P/06/0188	08/09/2006
App/U6925/A/06/1198891	Messrs Treharne and Price	Land to the rear of Susannah Place, Prosser Street and Windsor Place, Treharris	Residential Development	P/05/0408	02/06/2006	Allowed 22/09/06
App/U6925/A/06/1198995	Mr L Williams	Unit 13 EFI Industrial Estate, Brecon Road	Extension to Existing Industrial Unit	P/06/0020	02/06/2006
App/U6925/C/041168237	Michael Barrie Lynn	3 Newfoundlound Terrace, Merthyr Tydfil	Dormer window front roof plane	No planning application made	09/12/04	Dismissed 05/04/05
App/U6925/C/061200042, 1200043, 1200044, 1200045, 1200646	Mr MS Davies, Mrs BA Davies and Miss FG Davies	Ein LLe Hedychlon, Pontycapel Road, Cefn Coed	Unauthorised dwelling and stables	P/01/0345	27/10/06
App/U6925/A/06/1200210	Miss C Miles	20 The Grove, Aberfan	First floor and two storey rear extension	P/06/0401	02/11/06	Allowed 17/01/07
App/U6925/A/06/1199826	Mr K Oxenham	19 Raglan Grive, Castle Park, Merthyr Tydfil	Extension to a conservatory	P/06/0188	08/09/06	Dismissed 12/12/06
App/U6925/A/061200300	Miss N Mullins	1 Bishops Grove	Erection of side garage and rear conservatory	P/06/0283	09/11/06	Allowed 17/01/07
App/U6925/A/06/1200323	Mr and Mrs P Dacey	6 Chepstow Close, Castle Park, CF48 1JG	Front conservatory	P/06/0263	10/11/06